social media and self-esteemsocial media and self-esteem

You open the app to check one thing. Twenty minutes later, you’ve seen a bloke you went to school with standing in front of his new house, a kid half your age deadlifting twice what you can, and a mate’s family on a beach in Bali. You put the phone down feeling a bit flatter than when you picked it up, and you can’t quite say why.

Most of us know that feeling. There’s decent research on what’s behind it, and on what helps. Most articles on this topic are written with women and teenage girls in mind, but blokes cop a version of it too, and it doesn’t get talked about much.

Why scrolling can leave you feeling worse

Comparing ourselves to the people around us is how humans work out where we stand. That’s nothing new. What’s changed is who we’re comparing ourselves to.

Not that long ago, you measured yourself against your mates, your neighbours and the blokes at work, and you saw the whole picture, good days and ordinary ones. Online, you’re up against thousands of people, and you mostly see their best moments: the promotion, the holiday, the new ute, the six-pack. Nobody posts the overdue rego or the blue in the car on the way to the beach.

Psychologist Melissa Hunt from the University of Pennsylvania, who ran one of the best-known studies on this, puts it down to exactly that: looking at other people’s lives online sets off a lot of comparing, and the comparing drags your mood down. Even when you know it’s a highlight reel, it’s hard not to stack your everyday up against someone else’s best day.

How it hits blokes

The body stuff is real, and it’s growing. According to the Australian Psychological Society, as reported by the Butterfly Foundation, the share of men unhappy with their bodies has tripled over the past 25 years, from 15% to 45%. In one Australian study, researchers Marika Tiggemann and Isabella Anderberg showed men aged 18 to 30 a mix of images. The men who saw shirtless male Instagram influencers ended up noticeably less happy with their own bodies than the men who saw other pictures.

Part of the problem is that what you’re looking at isn’t always what it seems. When the ACCC, the competition watchdog, went through the accounts of 118 social media influencers, including 18 in health and fitness, it found 81% of their posts were potentially misleading under Australian Consumer Law. Butterfly Foundation also points out that some fitness influencers get their physiques with the help of performance and image-enhancing drugs they never mention.

Then there’s money. The young bloke with the Lambo, the crypto expert selling “passive income”, the 25-year-old with three investment properties. It’s built to make you feel like you’re falling behind, and usually to sell you something.

And blokes are often the last to say anything about how it’s affecting them, so it tends to build up quietly.

Is it getting to you?

A few honest questions worth asking yourself:

  • Do you reach for your phone without thinking, the moment there’s a gap in your day?
  • Do you often feel worse about your body, your job, your money or your life after scrolling?
  • Do you find yourself checking how many likes or views something got?
  • Has it pushed out things you used to enjoy, like a hobby, sport or catching up with mates?
  • Are you scrolling in bed when you should be asleep?

If you said yes to a couple of those, it’s probably worth making a few changes. That doesn’t mean anything’s wrong with you. Most of these apps are built to keep you scrolling.

What the research says about cutting back

The best-known experiment on this was run at the University of Pennsylvania in 2018. Researchers split 143 students into two groups. One kept using social media as normal, and the other limited Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat to 10 minutes each a day, about 30 minutes in total, for three weeks.

The group that cut back reported significantly less loneliness and depression than the group that didn’t. The biggest improvement was in the people who’d been feeling most down when the study started.

The detail that rarely gets mentioned is that self-esteem itself didn’t change much. There was no significant difference between the two groups. People felt less lonely and less down, but they didn’t rate themselves any higher. Both groups also became a little less anxious and had less fear of missing out, and the researchers think that came from simply paying attention to their phone use.

In other words, cutting back helps with your mood, and just keeping track of your habits helps too. But feeling good about yourself probably also needs some wins in real life, not just less time online.

What actually helps

Start by checking your screen time. iPhones and Android phones both show how long you spend in each app, and most people get a shock the first time they look. Knowing the number is useful in itself.

Then set some limits. Use your phone’s built-in app timers on the apps that leave you feeling worst. The Pennsylvania study’s 10 minutes per app per day is a decent target if you want something concrete to aim for.

Clean up your feed. Unfollow or mute accounts that keep making you feel bad about your body, your bank balance or your life. You don’t owe anyone a follow. Swap them for accounts that teach you something, make you laugh or cover something you’re actually into.

Charge your phone in the kitchen, not beside the bed. Late at night is when the comparison stuff tends to hit hardest, and a cheap alarm clock does the job just fine.

Most of all, put the time somewhere else. Self-esteem comes from doing things, not watching other people do them. Catch up with your mates, coach the kids’ team, get stuck into a project in the shed or go camping. If the gym content is getting in your head, train against last month’s version of yourself, not a stranger on Instagram. Getting better at something simple, like push-ups, gives you a win that’s actually yours. And if you’ve got out of the habit of real conversations, I’ve written about how to start a conversation with anyone.

For dads

Since 10 December 2025, Australia has had a minimum age of 16 for social media accounts. Platforms including Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok and YouTube now have to take reasonable steps to stop under-16s having accounts. There are no penalties for kids or parents. It’s on the platforms.

It’s not watertight, though. In its March 2026 compliance update, the eSafety Commissioner said plenty of under-16s were still keeping or opening accounts, and it was investigating several of the major platforms. So it’s still worth talking with your kids about what they’re seeing online. The eSafety family hub has conversation starters if you’re not sure how to bring it up.

The most powerful thing you can do is set the example. If you’re scrolling at the dinner table, they’ll notice.

When it’s more than a bad day

Everyone has days when scrolling leaves them a bit flat. But if you’ve been feeling down, anxious or unhappy with yourself for more than a couple of weeks, or it’s affecting your sleep, work or relationships, talk to someone. Your GP is a good place to start, or a mate you trust. I’ve written about checking in on a mate who isn’t OK, and it’s just as true the other way round.

These services are there if you need them:

Social media isn’t all bad. It keeps you in touch with family, it’s how half the footy club organises itself, and there’s plenty of good stuff on there. Just use it on your terms, and remember that nobody’s life looks as good in person as it does in their best photo.

Cheers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *